 |
| Illustration: Phil Foster |
The companies censor on the government’s behalf. There’s ample precedent for calling it state action.
The media has panned Donald Trump’s First Amendment lawsuits against Facebook, Twitter and YouTube: “sure to fail,” “as stupid as you’d think,” “ridiculous.” Mr. Trump’s complaint omits important precedents, facts and claims for relief, but there’s a strong case to be made that social-media censorship violates the Constitution. If his lawyers do better in court than in their initial filing, Mr. Trump can win.
It’s true that the First Amendment ordinarily applies to the government rather than private companies. But the central claim in Mr. Trump’s class-action lawsuit—that the defendants should be treated as state actors and are bound by the First Amendment when they engage in selective political censorship—has precedent to back it up. Their censorship constitutes state action because the government granted them immunity from legal liability, threatened to punish them if they allow disfavored speech, and colluded with them in choosing targets for censorship.
The Supreme Court held in Norwood v. Harrison (1973) that the government “may not induce, encourage, or promote private persons to accomplish what it is constitutionally forbidden to accomplish.” As Jed Rubenfeld and I argued in these pages in January, that’s what Congress did by passing Section 230(c)(2) of the 1996 Communications Decency Act, which permits tech companies to censor constitutionally protected speech and immunizes them from state liability if they do so.
The high court has repeatedly held that federal immunity pre-empting state law can transform a private party’s conduct into state action subject to constitutional scrutiny. In Railway Employees’ Department v. Hanson (1956), the justices found state action in union-employer agreements because Congress had passed a statute immunizing such agreements from liability under state law. In Skinner v. Railway Labor Executives Association (1989), the court again found state action in a private company’s conduct because federal laws immunized companies from liability if they tested employees for drugs.
Prominent congressional Democrats have also issued severe, explicit and repeated threats to retaliate against social-media giants if they fail to remove “hate speech” and “misinformation” that the government can’t directly censor under the Constitution. These threats have worked.
In an October 2020 hearing, as Mr. Trump’s lawsuits note, Sen. Richard Blumenthal of Connecticut told CEOs Jack Dorsey of Twitter and Mark Zuckerberg of Facebook: “The president has used this microphone to spread vicious falsehoods and apparent attempt to overturn the will of the voters.” In the same hearing, he threatened “a breakup of the tech giants” and “Section 230 reform,” including “possible repeal.” Mr. Zuckerberg has called such regulations an “existential threat” to Facebook. In January both sites banned Mr. Trump. --->READ MORE HERE
 |
| Brandon Bell / Getty Images |
Google-owned video-sharing platform YouTube censored the American Conservative Union by removing an episode of “America UnCanceled,” a program on the ACU’s CPAC NOW network.
The taken-down episode featured information about former President Donald Trump’s America First Policy Institute-led class-action lawsuit against Big Tech, the ACU said in a news release.
“It is clear that YouTube censored CPAC because we stood with former President Donald Trump on his lawsuit against Big Tech,” ACU Chairman Matt Schlapp said.
“This is yet another example of Big Tech censoring content with which they disagree in order to promote the political positions they favor.”
On top of removing the episode from the platform, YouTube put a strike against the ACU’s YouTube account on Friday. --->READ MORE HEREFollow links below to related stories:
+++++YouTube deletes Trump video, freezes CPAC account+++++
WATCH: TRUMP Full Speach at CPAC2021 in Dallas, TX 07-11-21
Trump’s lawsuit against Big Tech has legal merit
‘It’s completely un-American’: Trump at CPAC attacks Big Tech for meddling in the 2020 election
Trump rips Biden, Big Tech and critical race theory at CPAC
Trump Easily Wins CPAC Straw Poll, Again Insinuates Stolen Election in Speech
Who Needs Twitter? Trump Sends Out a Flurry of Statements, Hints at What's Happening Behind the Scenes
‘You are just being played’: Trump tells GOP to stop infrastructure talks
Trump says McConnell 'wasting money' on Alabama Senate primary
Alaska GOP endorses Trump-backed challenger to Murkowski
Trump Sends a Message to GOP Lawmakers: You Are 'Being Played'
Crowd ERUPTS in USA chant as Donald Trump attends UFC fight
Donald Trump Endorses Ryan Zinke in Montana Congressional Bid
Trump’s Lawsuits Against Big Tech Will Go ‘All the Way’ to Supreme Court, Backers Say
Rupert Murdoch made the decision to call Arizona for Biden, new book says. Fox News denies the allegations
Trump headlines fundraiser for NYS Republican Party
Trump calls Terry McAuliffe a 'political HACK' as he rails against critical race theory in Virginia
Trump cheers on Youngkin in Virginia governor’s race: ‘Make Virginia Great Again’
If you like what you see, please "Like" us on Facebook either here or here. Please follow us on Twitter here.
No comments:
Post a Comment