Saturday, May 2, 2020

Federal Appeals Court Nixes Trump Policy of Tying Grants to Enforcement

AP Photo/Alex Brandon, File
A sharply worded ruling by a federal appeals court in Chicago on Thursday said the Trump administration policy of threatening to withhold grant money from so-called sanctuary cities to force them to comply with its more stringent immigration policies violates separation-of-powers provisions enshrined in the U.S. Constitution.
The 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals also said a freeze of that policy should extend nationwide, rejecting arguments by U.S. Department of Justice lawyers that if an injunction were OKed in the case it should only apply to the city of Chicago.
Broad executive-branch powers on immigration matters don’t include withholding money allocated by the legislative branch to pressure cities and states to comply with an executive-branch policy, said Judge Ilana Rovner, who authored the 95-page ruling.
“Such a concentration of power,” she said, “would allow tyranny to flourish, and our system of government is wisely set up by the Founders to foreclose such a danger.”
LINK: Federal Appeals Court Rules Against Trump 
Admin. Move to Block Funding from Sanctuary Cities
She added: “The separation of powers is a foundation of our government, not a formality to be swept aside on the path to achieving goals that the executive branch deems worthy. … The (grant) conditions imposed here are an executive usurpation of the power of the purse.”
One of the three judges on the panel, Daniel Manion, concurred with the bulk of the ruling. But he said in a separate opinion that he disagreed with approval of a nationwide injunction, saying that “broad, sweeping relief of such nature is rarely appropriate.”
Read the rest of the story HERE and follow links below to related stories:

Trump Loses Sanctuary City Fight With Chicago

Federal Appeals Court Rules Against Trump Admin. Move to Block Funding from Sanctuary Cities

If you like what you see, please "Like" us on Facebook either here or here. Please follow us on Twitter here.


No comments: